The Complete Guide to Elimination Communication: A Natural Approach to Early Potty Learning
When it comes to potty training, most of us are familiar with the typical path—waiting until our child reaches the age of 2 or 3 and then beginning the process. But what if there was another, more intuitive way? A way to guide your baby toward toilet independence without the stress of conventional potty training? That’s where Elimination Communication (EC) comes in.
While it might sound a little out there, EC is actually an ancient practice that is gaining momentum in the parenting world, and it’s more gentle than you might think. In fact, some parents swear by it for fostering a deeper connection with their babies while helping them develop important skills. But what exactly is EC, and why should you consider it?
Let’s explore this fascinating method, its benefits, the risks involved, and some practical tips to get started. By the end, you might just find yourself giving EC a try—and finding that it’s the right fit for your family’s journey!
The Evolution of Diapers and Toilet Training
Before we dive into Elimination Communication, let’s take a quick look at how we got here. The history of diapering and toilet training is a story of evolving technology, changing cultural practices, and new parenting philosophies.
For centuries, cloth diapers were the norm, and early potty training was common. But all that changed with the rise of disposable diapers in 1955. Disposable diapers offered an unprecedented level of convenience, and by the 1980s, they had become the standard, thanks to their affordability. This shift changed the way we viewed potty training.
As disposable diapers gained popularity, pediatricians like Dr. T. Berry Brazelton recommended a more relaxed, child-centered approach to toilet training. Rather than rushing to potty train at 18 months, parents were encouraged to wait until their child showed signs of readiness, leading to an average potty training age of around 30 months today. But, what if this shift could be challenged by something more natural and intuitive?
That’s where Elimination Communication comes into play.
What is Elimination Communication?
Elimination Communication, often referred to as Natural Infant Hygiene, is a gentle, intuitive approach to helping your baby recognize and communicate their need to eliminate waste. EC isn’t potty training in the traditional sense; instead, it’s about helping babies use the potty or a bowl from as early as infancy.
Ingrid Bauer’s 2001 book Diaper Free! The Gentle Wisdom of Natural Infant Hygiene helped popularize this practice in Western cultures. EC is based on the idea that babies, just like all mammals, have the natural ability to communicate their elimination needs. By observing cues—like a certain cry or subtle signs of restlessness—parents can assist their babies in using the toilet.
This practice may seem daunting at first, especially if you’re used to relying on diapers, but many parents around the world have found that EC isn’t just a practical solution—it also strengthens the bond between parent and child and can even lead to earlier potty independence.
It’s important to know that EC is NOT potty training, children will still need to be potty trained once they are able to control their bladder and bowels.
“Nature is the best teacher. She patiently waits and repeats the lesson in multiple ways until we learn.”
– Dr. Maria Montessori
Why Try Elimination Communication? The Benefits for Baby (and You)
Now that we know what EC is, you’re probably wondering—what’s in it for you and your baby? While the idea of no diapers might sound like a lot of work, there are actually several benefits to Elimination Communication that might make it worth considering.
- Health Benefits: Believe it or not, practicing EC can lead to fewer health problems for your baby. Babies who participate in EC are less likely to develop urinary tract infections (UTIs) later in life. This is because they’re learning to empty their bladder completely, which can help prevent the buildup of bacteria that causes UTIs.
- Fewer Diaper Changes and Less Discomfort: Many parents report that their babies cry less and seem more comfortable when EC is in practice. That’s because babies often cry when they need to eliminate, and responding to that need can reduce their discomfort. In some cases, parents have even found that EC helps with colicky symptoms—because the baby isn’t holding in waste or feeling the discomfort of a dirty diaper.
- Bladder Development and Potty Training Readiness: Research shows that babies who practice early toilet training tend to develop better bladder control. For example, in countries where early potty training is the norm (like Vietnam), babies develop full bladder control by around 9 months. In contrast, children in cultures where potty training is delayed until 3 years old often don’t gain full control until later.
- Easier Transition to Potty Training: Although EC isn’t full potty training, it sets the stage for a smoother transition when the time does come. Babies who’ve been gently guided to eliminate at the right times are often quicker to learn independent potty use.
- A Non-Coercive, Relaxed Approach: Unlike traditional potty training, which often involves trying to teach toddlers to “hold it” or rewarding them for using the potty, EC is all about following your baby’s natural rhythms. There’s no pressure, no stress—just a calm, communicative process that works for both you and your baby.
“The most powerful thing you can do for your child is to honor their natural rhythm.”
– Unknown
How Does Elimination Communication Work?
If you’re interested in trying EC, it’s actually simpler than it sounds! Here’s a step-by-step guide to getting started with this gentle approach.
- Observe Your Baby’s Signals: The key to EC is understanding your baby’s cues. Babies give subtle signals when they need to eliminate, whether it’s a particular cry, fussiness, or even just a stillness before they go. By observing your baby closely, you’ll start to recognize these signals and can respond accordingly.
- Timing Is Key: Babies often have predictable times when they need to eliminate—like after a nap or a meal. Try to offer the potty or a small bowl at these intervals, so your baby learns to associate those times with elimination.
- Use a Signal or Cue: You can create a sound or a signal that you consistently use while your baby is eliminating, such as “shhh” or “sss.” Eventually, your baby will associate the sound with the action and start to understand what it means.
- Trust Your Intuition: As you practice EC, you may begin to intuitively feel when your baby needs to go. Some parents report a deep connection with their baby during this process, almost like a sixth sense when it comes to elimination cues!
- Respond Calmly and Gently: EC is about communication, not pressure. If your baby has a “miss” or doesn’t go when you think they should, don’t worry. There are no “accidents” here, just learning moments. The goal is to keep the process as low-stress and positive as possible.
- Babywearing Can Help: Many parents find that wearing their baby in a sling or carrier helps them tune into their baby’s elimination rhythms. Babies in carriers are less likely to eliminate until they’re in the right position, so this can make EC a lot easier.
My Personal Journey with Elimination Communication: Finding a Balance
The idea of not having to change poopy diapers is tempting, right? I mean, who wouldn’t want to skip those diaper changes and minimize waste? But the reality of practicing Elimination Communication (EC) isn’t as simple as it may sound. While many parents who embrace EC choose to go completely diaper-free from the start, that approach felt completely unrealistic for me—especially as a first-time mom who hadn’t been around babies much. The thought of adding another layer of responsibility, on top of the already overwhelming demands of a newborn, seemed too much to handle.
I’d read about the benefits of EC—how it could lead to fewer diaper changes, reduce discomfort from dirty diapers, and potentially lead to earlier potty training. However, after returning to work, I realized I just didn’t have the bandwidth to dive into a full-blown, diaper-free lifestyle.
That is, until my baby girl, at 3 months old, developed a terrible diaper rash. It was so bad that I decided to go all in and kept her naked for an entire week. Luckily, I was on vacation from work, so I had the time to manage the situation. But let me tell you, by day two, both of us were covered in pee, and I was running out of clean towels. That’s when it hit me: this was the perfect time to try EC.
We started by buying a few puppy pads (as a mess-free solution) and a little top hat potty. For the first week, I focused on offering the potty to her after naps and feedings—basically following her natural rhythms. It took me the entire week to even start recognizing when she was about to go, but slowly, we got into a rhythm. After her rash cleared up, I had to return to work, and so we went back to using diapers for a bit. This shift made us a “half-time” EC family, and you know what? It worked! My poopy diaper count is about half, and I consider that a big win!
However, I’ll be honest with you—actively practicing EC while working outside the home can be a challenge. It’s tough to do the full diaper-free approach unless you’re at home all day. There’s a steep learning curve, and it takes dedication, patience, and some trial and error until you understand your baby’s cues and develop a routine. With all the other demands of parenting and managing a household, I found it was just too much to juggle at first.
For me, using diapers as a “safety net” while practicing EC on the side was the perfect solution. I found that even partial EC is still effective and has plenty of benefits. If you’re working or have other commitments, this flexible approach to EC might be the most practical. And if you have the time and patience to fully dive into it, I believe the long-term benefits are definitely worth it.
Important Things to Keep in Mind
Before you start EC, there are a few things to consider. Some pediatricians, particularly those with expertise in urology, may have concerns about EC leading babies to hold in their waste, which can cause issues like constipation or urinary problems. However, as long as you approach EC gently and stay mindful of your baby’s needs, this shouldn’t be a concern.
Also, it’s important to remember that EC is not a race. It’s a gradual, ongoing process, and your baby’s readiness is key. There’s no need to force anything—just trust the journey!
“The greatest gift you can give your child is a lifetime of love.”
– Unknown
This post may contain affiliate links. When you buy through links or my site, I may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. Also, the information on this site is NOT intended to be medical advice. Please seek professional medical care if needed. See disclosures for more information.
Practical Tips for Getting Started with Elimination Communication:
- Observe your baby’s elimination patterns and note when they typically need to go.
- Create a cue sound or signal, like “shhh” or “sss,” and use it consistently.
- Watch for signs of discomfort or restlessness, which often mean your baby needs to eliminate.
- Use babywearing to help sync up with your baby’s rhythms.
- Go at your own pace—there’s no rush! EC is about learning together and developing a deeper bond.
Final Thoughts
Elimination Communication might seem unconventional, but for many families, it offers a gentle, connected approach to potty training. It’s a slower, more natural way of guiding your baby toward toilet independence—and it could be exactly what you’re looking for.
So, if you’re curious about EC, start by observing your baby’s signals. You might be surprised at how much they communicate already! No matter where you are in your parenting journey, remember that there’s no one-size-fits-all approach—what matters most is what works best for your family.
Whether you give EC a try or stick with traditional potty training, the goal is the same: a confident, healthy, and happy little one ready to tackle the next phase of life!
References
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8196082/
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0306987718310260
https://www.eliminationcommunicationbabies.com/explore/posts/517492-elimination-communication-research-study-and-
https://skeptoid.com/blog/2015/01/06/elimination-communication-your-baby-is-speaking-to-you-about-poop/
https://parentingscience.com/infant-toilet-training/
https://www.healthline.com/health/childrens-health/potty-training-methods
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/00099228221145268?journalCode=cpja
https://www.bedwettingandaccidents.com/single-post/2015/02/20/elimination-communication-bad-news
https://www.naturalbirthandbabycare.com/elimination-communication/
https://www.mamanatural.com/baby-elimination-communication/
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0306987714002229
https://www.today.com/parents/no-diapers-no-potty-training-no-kidding-practice-elimination-communication-1c7398317
https://foreverymom.com/family-parenting/dangers-potty-training-too-early-dr-steve-hodges/
https://www.northcarolinahealthnews.org/2014/11/12/not-too-early-or-too-late-potty-training-timing-needs-to-be-just-right/
https://www.dovepress.com/the-association-of-age-of-toilet-training-and-dysfunctional-voiding-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-RRU
https://www.ittakesavillagesemo.com/potty-learning/img/age.jpg
https://pottygenius.com/blogs/blog/the-history-of-potty-training
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24962210/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32422498/
https://www.ecpeesy.com/elimination-communication-potty-independence/
https://parentingscience.com/potty-training-age/
https://parentingscience.com/science-of-toilet-training/
